Episode 96: Probiotics and Gut Health: Do You Really Need One?

Gut Health
Written By Nicole Goode
 

Do you really need a probiotic? In this episode of The Goode Health Podcast, we discuss what probiotics are, how they affect your gut microbiome, and whether they’re essential or just overhyped. We break down the science so you can make smart decisions about your gut health.

You’ll learn the real pros and cons: how some probiotic strains support digestion, immunity, and gut barrier integrity, and why others may offer little benefit. We debunk common myths, highlight limitations, and give you a clear 5-step guide to choosing a high-quality probiotic that’s worth your time and money.

This episode answers questions like:

“Do probiotics actually help gut health?”

“Do probiotics improve digestive health and immune function?”

“How to choose effective probiotic strains & dosages”

“Which foods help the gut microbiome best”

“Role of inflammation in gut health and systemic health”

By the end of this episode, you’ll have concrete tools to assess whether you should add a probiotic to your routine, and if so, how to pick the best one. If you’ve been wondering about immunity, bloating, mental clarity, or long-term health through the lens of gut health, this is your go-to guide.

DISCLAIMER: The content in this podcast and related website is not intended to be a substitute for medical advice. It is not intended to be used to diagnose or treat, instead it is designed to help educate and inspire. Always seek the advice of a professional medical practitioner or qualified health practitioner. Never ignore or disregard advice given to you based on information in this podcast or related website and do not delay in seeking medical advice.

 

Timestamps:

[01:30] - What is “Gut Health” & Why It Matters
Discover why gut health is about more than bloating or IBS symptoms, it impacts immunity, hormones, energy, and even mood.

[03:50] - Should You Be Taking a Probiotic Right Now?
Unpacking one of the most common questions: who benefits from probiotics, and when might they not be necessary?

[06:35] - What Exactly Are Probiotics?
A clear definition of probiotics, how they differ from prebiotics and postbiotics, and why strains matter.

[11:00] - Not All Probiotics Affect Your Gut the Same Way
Learn why different strains have different effects on the gut microbiome, from digestion to skin health to mental wellbeing.

[13:10] - Proven Benefits of Probiotics: Digestion, Immunity, Barrier Health
How certain probiotics support digestion, boost immunity, balance hormones, and strengthen the gut barrier.

[16:40] - Limitations and Side Effects of Probiotics
The risks, downsides, and situations where probiotics may not be effective, or may even worsen symptoms.

[19:10] - Common Myths About Probiotics Debunked
Addressing common misconceptions like “all probiotics are the same” or “yogurt is enough.”

[21:25] - How to Choose the Right Probiotic (5 Steps)
A practical guide to evaluating strains, dosages, delivery methods, and quality before you buy.

[24:00] - My Top 4 Probiotic Products
Clinically backed probiotics I recommend in clinic, plus why delivery method and strain specificity matter.

 
“One of the biggest questions I hear in clinic is, ‘Should I be taking a probiotic?’ The truth is, probiotics can be powerful tools, but only when chosen wisely. They’re not quick fixes, and they can’t undo a poor diet or high stress. What they can do is strengthen your gut barrier, calm inflammation, improve digestion, and even impact hormones and mood when the right strain is matched to the right person.”
— Nicole Goode
 

Essential learnings from this episode…

  • Not all probiotics are created equal. Different strains and dosages have different effects; you need to match the strain to your goal (digestion, immunity, mood, etc.).

  • Probiotics can help with immunity and gut barrier health. Some strains support immune response and help reduce “leaky gut” or intestinal permeability.

  • There are limitations and risks. Side effects, lack of regulation, and low-quality products can reduce effectiveness or lead to wasted time/money.

  • Common beliefs like “more CFUs = better” or “any probiotic works for all gut issues” are often misleading.

  • Your biology, diet, existing microbiome, and health goals should guide whether you need a probiotic at all.

 
 

Thank You For Tuning In

We are so grateful for you tuning in today to our podcast. If you enjoyed today’s show, you can really help us spread the word by sharing the episode and joining in on the conversation over on Instagram @goode_health. 

Rating and reviewing the episode is highly helpful, I promise I read every single one and reviewing the show really helps us in the podcast charts.

Finally, don’t forget to subscribe to the show on your favourite podcast player so that you don’t miss an episode! 

Nicole Goode
Next

Episode 95: Are Supplements Worth It? How to Choose the Right Ones